Proposed Deal Could Slash Toxic Emissions in America’s ‘Cancer Alley’

Consent decree on two suits against the EPA by residents of one of most polluted parts of Louisiana would lead to a review of federal air pollutant standards.

A proposed legal settlement between the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and residents of the town of Reserve, Louisiana could significantly reduce toxic emissions in one of the most polluted parts of the US.

The stretch of the Mississippi River between New Orleans and Baton Rouge is nicknamed “Cancer Alley” because of its concentration of petrochemical facilities. In April, the EPA began investigating whether state agencies had violated Black residents rights in granting a number of permits to allow certain plants to operate in the region. Photo by Ken Lund.

Announced on Tuesday via the federal register, the proposed agreement, known as a consent decree, would settle two lawsuits partly brought against the EPA by members of the predominantly Black community in St John the Baptist parish, the epicenter of the region known colloquially as “Cancer Alley”.

The agreement would lead the EPA to conduct a review of its air pollutant standards and potentially make new rules governing emissions for petrochemical plants in the region.

Reserve, a small community in St John the Baptist parish, is home to the most air polluted census tract in the US, where data collected by the EPA estimates the cancer-risk rate is 50 times the national average. The community, and the Cancer Alley region, is the subject of an reporting series by the Guardian called Cancer Town.

The high cancer-risk rate in Reserve is largely attributable to a synthetic rubber plant that borders the community, operated by the Japanese chemicals giant Denka. It is the only location in America to emit the likely human carcinogen chloroprene.

The EPA’s recommended lifetime exposure limit to chloroprene emissions is currently 0.2 micrograms per cubic meter. In 2017, shortly after Denka purchased the plant from the American company DuPont, which operated the facility for decades and sold it after fearing the EPA would begin to regulate its emissions, the Japanese firm committed to reducing emissions by 85%. But air monitoring around the plant shows that emissions regularly exceed the EPA guideline, sometimes by dozens of times.

In one of the lawsuits potentially settled by the consent decree, the EPA was sued for alleged violations of the Clean Air Act for failing to control chloroprene emissions, as well as host of other pollutants including the human carcinogens ethylene oxide and formaldehyde.

According to the proposed consent decree, the EPA will take action on potential new “necessary” revisions to standards by March next year, with a “final action” in 2024.

Related Reading
EPA Opens Civil Rights Investigations over Pollution in Cancer Alley

Agency will look at whether Black citizens’ rights were violated in polluted industrial corridor in Louisiana.

Taking on Petrochemical Giants

This grassroots group is fighting for environmental justice in Louisiana’s “Cancer Alley,” and winning.

Lawyers at the nonprofit group Earth Justice, who represent the Concerned Citizens of St John, described the draft consent decree as “an important step along the path toward finally strengthening the protection from cancer-causing toxic air that community members in St John have been breathing for years”.

They added: “The ultimate test will be whether EPA listens to St. John community members, follows the science and strengthens air toxics standards to protect public health. Facilities’ emissions of chloroprene and other extremely toxic chemicals are especially hazardous to children’s health and well-being and need immediate attention.”
In a statement, Denka (DPE) spokesman Jim Harris said the company would review the draft consent decree and maintained its long standing position that the plant’s emissions resulted in “no increased levels of health impacts in the area surrounding DPE’s facility”.

The statement added: “DPE will continue to work with the EPA to ensure the best available science is used in future rule making.”

The proposed settlement follows a series of new enforcement moves in the region after Joe Biden’s EPA administrator Michael Regan toured St John and other parishes last year, pledging to do more to support communities affected by air pollution.

In April, the EPA opened a number of civil rights investigations into state agencies to examine whether they violated Black residents rights in granting a number of permits to allow certain plants to operate in the region. The EPA has also announced it will conduct unannounced inspections of certain facilities in Louisiana and elsewhere as it ramps up enforcement efforts.

Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our biweekly newsletter.

You Make Our Work Possible

You Make Our Work Possible

We don’t have a paywall because, as a nonprofit publication, our mission is to inform, educate and inspire action to protect our living world. Which is why we rely on readers like you for support. If you believe in the work we do, please consider making a tax-deductible year-end donation to our Green Journalism Fund.

Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our biweekly newsletter.

The Latest

Mountain Valley Pipeline Pushed Forward on False Claims of Need

Claims that MVP is needed for energy security or demand — or that it is nearly built and has no legal hurdles ahead — are contradicted by data.

Michele Bustamante, Amy Mall, and Tom Rutigliano

Spanish Firm’s Plans to Farm Octopuses Raises Ethical Quandaries

The idea should be nixed before it ever becomes a reality, say activists and researchers.

Zoe Loftus-Farren

In Sarawak, Justice Delayed is Justice Denied

As Malaysian timber giant Samling’s SLAPP suit against SAVE Rivers is adjourned for a fourth time, communities continue their fight against the logging company.

Fiona McAlpine

In this Arctic Town, Movements Triggered by Water Pose the Biggest Challenge

The “green shift” isn’t enough, says mayor of Longyearbyen, which is warming faster than anywhere else on Earth.

Randall Hyman

Chevron’s Carbon Offsets are Mostly Worthless and Some May Cause Harm, Research Says

Investigation finds energy giant’s efforts to offset its huge emissions rely on schemes with little impact.

Nina Lakhani The Guardian

‘Six Times the Size of Yosemite’: The New Tribal Sanctuary Off the Super-Rich LA Coast

Viewed by the Chumash people as their ancestral home, the Native American tribe is behind the first Indigenous-led initiative to protect the ocean and repair its damaged ecosystem.

Lucy Sherriff The Guardian